Monday, March 23, 2009

Talking: Co-constructing knowledge




Synopsis: Diverse members of the team can contribute inputs from different angles. The group gains more insight of reality.


Clear distinctions of space and time exist in people’s minds in diversity.

Getting across

The more dimensions there are, the more the requirement for a better understanding of issues and their circumstances. Diverse members of the team can contribute inputs from different angles. The multiplicity helps the collective thinking become more rounded. The group gains more insight of reality and considers creative innovations to resolve them.

Issues and problems that create obstacles to workflow arise from different situations. They may also have different contexts and run different courses.
The solutions then need to be designed to fit.


Two cognitive levels

Members verbalizing their inner speech are then vital to finding these new courses of action. Our intellectual development occurs at two cognitive levels. According to social scientist Lev Vygotsky, these are:



· Actual development: where the individual is capable of independently dealing with issues and solving related problems.
· Potential development: this constitutes the "zone of proximal development" where the individual needs assistance in dealing with challenges. The interactions with others are crucial for guidance or collaboration.



Learning continues through our lifetime in the zone of proximal development. Much of it is collaborative in nature, impossible to separate from the social context. As we gain in experience and expertise, the learning consolidates as actual cognitive development.

Learning

Learning does not occur simply with the intake of book knowledge. Vygotsky argues that all cognitive functions originate in, and are products of social interactions. By interacting freely and openly, we put the knowledge to test. In the process, we are always learners.

Consolidating learning also depends significantly on the individual's internal drive to understand and promote the learning process. With this inner drive, we develop even as we age. Without it, we tend to resist change.

Collaborative learning methods diffuse the required motivation person to person. In the process, learners develop teamwork. Individual learning and successful group learning are thus mutually related. Collaborations build up an atmosphere of mutual trust, respect and acceptance within the group. The system thus builds its own culture and values in diversity.





Co-constructing

Through the social interactions, individuals in the group can receive other people’s points of view, as well as present their own. Just talking together allows them to discover new ways of communicating their thought processes.

A close knit group, even with members of different cultures, develops a common language – like slang or verbal shorthand - that bind group experiences together. From shared learning, the cognitive structures may be utilized in new or innovative ways. People become more effective in adapting to environments and to change.

Being averse to ‘conflict’ among people of the system could inhibit creative thought or prevent its expression. To discourage talking amongst the collective is to retard processes of collective learning and problem solving. Fact is we don’t construct knowledge just by ourselves, but largely ‘co-construct’ it with others in the environment.


Comments/opinions, anyone??


References for ‘Talking’ and 'Problem solving' blogposts:

Social Constructivism
Why Vygotsky?

Thursday, March 19, 2009

Talking: Focus on agenda



Synopsis: Minimizing personal contacts in organizations also minimizes lateral communications, preventing people from just talking to one another to create a common culture.



Differences, most organizations believe, will lead to conflict.

Talking

So they prefer to minimize personal contacts between members of the workforce. Keeping focused on the business agenda ensures a conflict-free work environment. It prevents time being wasted or interpersonal issues being raised. The trouble is it also minimizes lateral communications, preventing people from just talking to one another to create a common culture.



People are constantly talking around issues and solutions - in their minds. It is a conscious, purposive reflection on experience and learning. New perspectives are integrated into existing ideas, abilities and actions. This inner speech includes thinking slightly ahead of the present moment. That is, extending reasoning into the future, where outcomes will be met.

Its decisive power depends on each individual’s links with environmental factors, like other theories or other people. When people are familiar with one another these links are strong, and they are encouraged to share their thoughts and focus on issues and problems.

Culturally defined

Language and culture play a large role in our intellectual development. They actually define us, in how we tend to perceive worlds beyond our sensory data. Colour and shape that we see externally is transformed in throughput, to make sense as the things we see around us.


We assign meanings to environmental objects accordingly. For example, our eyes might see something round and black with two hands. Our minds then interpret the incoming data to mean ‘clock’.

More views

Diversity causes dimensions to multiply. Increasingly societies are becoming composed of various demographic groups. This means that the individual has to contend with more cultures, more languages, and more views than ever before.

Homogeneity among people makes communicating easy. Words, nuances and connotations are easily understood. But getting sense and meaning across those not sharing the same culture and language is harder, obviously because the words or signs that they will correctly understand need to be found.

Weak social and language skills inhibit group discussions. Cultural barriers stop people contributing their own thoughts to the group. Many in the workforce simply await instructions for task assignments.


Effective talk

Just talking outside the business agenda is an important aspect of social interactions. Heterogeneous groups get to know one another’s backgrounds, and can clarify boundaries, and express opinions, intentions and solutions. It helps in teamwork to fathom where one is coming from, or intending to get to.

Diverse people need to be just talking together to share knowledge, experiences, perspectives, and even feelings. It makes them aware of denotative and connotative words. They begin to catch on to undertones, nuances and idiomatic turns of speech.

Their interactions facilitate increasing the multicultural workgroup’s knowledge base and problem solving capability. The team members explore and present fresh angles, processes and options. The group, alerted by disagreements, can focus critical attention on the obstacles that are stalling the flow at work, or may do so in the future.


Cont’d 2…co-constructing knowledge

Sunday, March 15, 2009

Appraisals: The drive to excel



Synopsis: The drive to excel comes from within. Management needs to facilitate the involvement of employee in decisions at work.


Extrinsic motivators, like monetary rewards, are generally relied upon to ensure the workflow. But with overuse they tend to carry unintended negative consequences.

Intrinsic motivation

For example, in the context of work, people begin to assume that the tasks are actually unpleasant and hence the money offered is actually the sugarcoating being offered. The employees may learn to expect extras every time a task is to be fulfilled.

Besides, the appreciation of the workforce as responsible, thinking human beings begins to diminish. Fact is the quality of performance depends not only on targets or incentives, but also on the emotional involvement of workforce members with the work decisions. Optimal work performance requires self-reliance, self-determination and intrinsic motivation. Basically, the drive to excel comes from within each person. People should want to work.

Once people buy in on a particular issue, their emotional arousal monitors and sustains the quality of their activity, through:


  • Generation of action - the tendency, readiness and decision to act on a plan, intention or preferred option.
  • Execution and control of action - the mode of execution and its degree of intensity.
  • Explanation of action – the context perceived from a personal point of view.
  • Rationale - justifications for the action.


Emotions influence the direction and energy of action performed, and are crucial for its success. Else, people simply go through the motions of doing.



Evolvement

Assumptions underlying the appraisals must change – for instance, that the individual is responsible for organizational success, and that improving their performance alone improves organizational performance.

The onus, the experts say is rather on the organization to create a different culture, and shift its business perspective from profits to people, from theory X to theory Y. Non-controlling positive feedback, and the acceptance of others’ perspective are important, contextually. Individual freedom, autonomy and trust during interactions with the organization and system-at-large needs support.

In diversity today, Frederick Taylor’s scientific management principle of separating decisions from work may have outlived its utility. The growing need is an evolvement from past practices. Because meanwhile, the quality of the workforce has changed drastically. It is now necessary to include workgroup members in work decisions.

The key areas

Authors Tom Coens and Mary Jenkins suggest a systems approach in key areas of human resources. The changes they advocate include:

Coaching - disconnecting its need from the PA process, and use goal setting only when it’s effective.
Feedback – initiating a bottom up process, moving employees towards gaining knowledge and new learning.
Motivation - developing intrinsic motivation so people find meaning in what they do.
Career pathways – decoupling promotions, career advancement, employee development, and downsizing decisions, from appraisals and each other.
Poor performers - helping the individual reach a satisfactory performance level, secure better job fit, or a respectful release.


Work output ultimately depends on the individual’s subjective commitment to the job. Appraisals should motivate people to generate optimal activity. But as post-mortems linked to reward and punishment, performance appraisals become intimidating and adversarial for the workforce.


Comments/opinions, anyone??


References for 'appraisals' blogposts:


Rethinking Performance Appraisals: A Book Review
About winning - carrots and sticks [article no. 1416 on twmacademy.com]

Wednesday, March 11, 2009

Appraisals: Measuring success?



Synopsis: With assumptions built into the performance appraisal process, context is generally missed.


Theorists say that each job should be directed towards the objectives of the business, the success of the whole. Performance appraisals (PA) are meant to identify and measure, so that this success may be managed.

The assumptions

Built into the PA process are assumptions that:


  • One appraisal process can effectively serve several functions at the same time – like training, promotions, compensation, etc.
  • People want and need to know where they stand, and appraisals tell them so, i.e., they provide accurate performance feedback.
  • The organization and the supervisor are responsible for individual employees’ morale, performance, and development – and PAs help to motivate the employees.

The PA decides the organizational value of the people. It’s relied on to regulate outputs and manage resources.

Differing focus

But critics say that when management focus is solely on the bottomline, the targets set are often unrealistic and impossible to reach. In most companies, PAs also turn out to be the only source of employee feedback.

As a result employees may spend much of their time dissatisfied with their last review or dreading the next one. Their work focus then shifts – from actual performance on the job to calculation of rewards.


Inequity


Interest in the work itself diminishes, and workforce members compete for favours from authority instead. What gets measured gets done or enhanced. Obviously other aspects of the job may be ignored.

Employees realize that they don’t own their job decisions; they don’t have control over their work. And thence, many don’t feel accountable for it either. The sense of teamwork or a collective performance for the organization is lost. When the tasks are complex, or there is inequity between effort and remuneration, working hard may soon become hardly working!

The burden


One PA to feed many channels is a "bureaucratic burden" that interferes with performance and wastes resources. It pressures individual, group and organization, with numerous hours of preparation, extensive paperwork and psychologically stressful interactions. The employee at work is made to feel the sword of Damocles hanging overhead.


In knowledge-based situations, many managers are unhappy themselves with using the PA process on members of their teams. Documentation of individual performance could imply serious performance problems even when there aren’t any.



Missing context


Surveys conducted through the ‘90s showed that between 80 and 90 percent of appraisals are ineffective. Should organizations then stop measuring performance?


No, say performance consultants, because measurement of performance and its feedback is critical for a high performing unit. However, they point out, the performance appraisals as practiced, generally miss the “adult-to-adult context”.


Fact is the workforce is also an organizational stakeholder. In knowledge-based systems, their intellectual capacities form the business platform. It is difficult to pin numbers on these contributions. The organization that relies overly on targets achieved fails to recognise the efforts involved, and effects of the circumstances surrounding the performance process. It fails in its duty to its internal customers - the workforce - and in alienating them, loses long-term effectiveness.


Cont’d 2… the drive to excel

Saturday, March 7, 2009

Risk: Relying on habit


Synopsis: Persistent ‘risk taking’ is now associated with conditions of stress and mental health problems.


Plagued by uncertainty and indecision, people tend to back risks, especially if they worked in the past.




Job stress

Many thus play ‘safe’ with risks on the job. To de-stress from its pressures, people in increasing numbers also play the odds. These facilitate their eventual preoccupation with winning, or attempting to recouping losses.

For example:

  • A survey study of 43,000 Americans found that more than a quarter gambled five or more times a year – from playing cards for money, to buying lottery tickets, and betting on sports games.
  • A research on the habits of office workers (Morse, January 2007) found that one in three workers gambles during work time, at least once a week and for at least 15 minutes.
The figures are on the rise in other parts of the world as well.

Goal change

The goal sought changes from effective decision-making action to anticipating the pleasures of a win. The attempt to call correct becomes the dependable strategy at work and in life. Failures or losses do not encourage rethinking the underlying premises, but the same strategy and its consequence repeats over and over again.

The habits of risk taking and gambling share the same neural networks in the brain. Hence one can soon lead to the other. A study reported in Forbes showed that continual risk taking could become like a narcotic, a way of coping with the pressure. The degree of anticipation grows with each successive strike, and so does the drive to win.

Rewards in the mind

Persistent ‘risk taking’ is now associated with conditions of stress and mental health problems. People afraid to lose, rely on this decisional process although it neither guarantees nor sustains success. Researchers implicate both individual attitudes and organizational culture in nurturing this type of decision-making.

The repetitive behaviour is a clear pattern of cumulative stress as the ‘rewards’ are only in the mind. Beating the odds to win is the consuming passion – the addiction. It pushes people further into stress and prolongs their fear of the unknown and future uncertainties. Even responsible managers can fall prey to the addiction to winning.

Using resources

The attempt is to control the environment with a reliance on odds. Despite prevailing circumstances, past assumptions about success with standard received wisdom, or best practices in ‘the way things have always been around here’, also remain the same. The preference for the ‘familiar’ stems from the individual and organizational desire to conserve resources.

In unknown situations, the resources needed, like critical thinking and reasoning, are far greater. New knowledge about changing environments helps develop our abilities to adapt to them. Improving adaptation facilitates our learning new ways to combat change and its challenges. We become more equipped and adept at dealing with uncertain times.
Comments/opinions, anyone??
References for ‘Risk’ blogposts:

Are You An Unhealthy Gambler?

Thinking twice [Article no: 84 on website twmacademy.com]

Tuesday, March 3, 2009

Risk: Current to future

Synopsis: People prefer ‘risky’ situations to those they consider unknown.


Effective decision-making is hard, as clearly apparent in the global forum. Many of today’s problems result from decisional errors of the past.


Decision steps

The decision making process should logically follow certain steps:


  • Defining the current problem
  • Analysing the problem
  • Developing alternative solutions
  • Evaluating alternatives thinking future
  • Selecting suitable action contextually
  • Implementing the decision
  • Following up on action
  • Receiving feedback
Considering both current needs and future uncertainties helps gear decisions towards the future where their effects will be felt. But people under pressure to perform tend to focus on current outcomes, leaving the future to take care of itself. The variables overlooked generally interfere in time, with goals.

Uncertainty

The new millennium has forced environmental change that includes:

  • World disasters
  • The general economic climate
  • Globalization
  • Male/female dynamics

Uncertainty is a part of the new reality. Survey studies conducted even before the current recession showed that more than 50 percent of the companies surveyed were undergoing major changes most of the time, and two out of three people felt a constant uncertainty.

The push for twice the work in half the time, flatter organizations, downsizing and outsourcing, made lay-offs a regular happening through the 1990s. The economic recession begun in the West is now causing massive losses of investments, jobs and even homes in many parts of the world. Work related stress is on the rise – on employees who have to leave, but perhaps more, on those who remain.


Go-getting

People try to deal with the stress by taking more risks. Traditionally, risk taking has been the hallmark of the aggressive businessperson, the fearless buccaneering spirit that achieves the impossible against all odds. Americans, for example, have long been considered “a nation of risk takers” with natural go-getting talent to do anything.

But indiscriminate risk taking actually means “short-circuiting” the decisional process – gambling, in other words. Thus people become unaware of or ignore the uncertainties/challenges of the environment, and of time. The resulting over-stimulation of the reward centres of the brain leads to anticipating the pleasures of immediate success. Much of today’s economic meltdown has resulted from such aggressive overreach.

Two networks

In studies were conducted with experimental betting games, the players could choose bets on two different card decks. One, labelled ‘risky’, contained identified odds. In the other labelled ‘ambiguous’, risks were unidentified. Researchers observed that people prefer to bet on the ‘risky’ deck, and tend to avoid exploring the unknown represented by the ‘ambiguous’ .

Recordings of brain activity showed two distinctly different networks activate in the brain in situations perceived as ‘known’ and ‘unknown’. Player perceptions of the situation is important in determining which specific network is activated.


In situations perceived unknown, twenty-four brain centres are activated including intelligence and emotions. Obviously it takes time and effort to understand and identify challenges. Where risk is perceived already identified, only the reward centres in the brain comes alive with anticipation of a lucky strike.


Cont’d 2…relying on habit

Tuesday, February 24, 2009

Women: The power of pink


Synopsis: Advertisement campaigns disperse through widespread media networks what every politician or individual seeking fame fears – public ridicule.


The incidents of male political activists assaulting young women in Mangalore’s pubs and public transport vehicles has outraged progressive women’s groups around the country.

Pink campaign

The “Consortium of Pubgoing, Loose and Forward Women” formed spontaneously on 5 February 2009, ballooned its random membership since to close to fifty thousand women and men. The Consortium launched a campaign for an “imaginative” fight back.


The campaign agenda is to:


  • Send the Sri Ram Sena some love – in the form of pink chaddis (briefs/panties).
  • Photograph and post online pictures of the underwear.
  • Do a Pub Bharo (fill the pubs) on Valentine’s Day.

The Sena leader initially said he would gift saris in return, but perhaps the sheer numbers required to do so would probably have proved overwhelming!

‘Gandhigiri’


The campaign is reminiscent of the ‘gandhigiri’ (Gandhism) portrayed in the blockbuster Hindi comedy film Lage Raho Munnabhai. Munnabhai is a don of the underworld. But Mahatma Gandhi inspires him. He envisions conversations with ‘Bapu’, as the Father of the Nation is affectionately addressed.



The interactions influence his behaviour profoundly, and his ‘Gandhi’ alter ego convinces him that coercive tactics are ineffective in the long-term. Munna vows to do whatever Gandhi would have done in conflict situations, however hard it may be. Eventually he abandons his natural proclivity to fix problems with fists, following instead the paths of truth and non-violence.

Thence when confronted with the intransigence of corruption in office, Munna resorts to sending flowers to the incumbents until they have a change of heart and mind!

Votes more treasured

The BJP is in power currently in the state of Karnataka. At the national level, this party had lost their mandate to governance earlier, when a single no-confidence vote in Parliament brought down their coalition government before the end of term. Subsequently, they were replaced at the Centre by the present Congress-led union government.

With general elections right around the corner, political parties focus on cleaning up their image. Votes are now far more treasured. They realize that supporting such attempts to impose ‘tradition’ on women in a democracy could hurt electoral chances.

The BJP high command and its state Chief Minister have condemned the attacks and distanced from the local outfit. Severely criticized around the country for their inaction, the state police arrested about 27 activists for the pub attacks, and just before Valentine’s Day, took many more, including the group’s leader, Pramod Mutalik, into preventive custody.

Networking power

Reactions to the assault on women are snowballing. The dairy products company, Amul, has picked up on the issue in its posters, with the telling caption “pink chaddi, yellow buddy”. These advertisement campaigns disperse through widespread media networks what every politician or individual seeking fame fears – public ridicule.

The Consortium has a longer-term goal of getting the message through to political leaders that “beating up women” is not at all an Indian cultural tradition. If oppressed women in corners of the country should realize consequently that they are neither alone nor defenceless in the age of connectivity, such campaigns will have served effective purpose.

Comments/opinions, anyone??

Reference:
Consortium of Pubgoing, Loose and Forward Women

Friday, February 20, 2009

Women: The moral policing


Synopsis: The question the assaulted women ask is “whom do we turn to?”


Asian women have been chained to tradition over centuries. Subservience to male influences and monogamous marriages is the accepted practice.

Increasing domination

Education and employment, that many women choose today, alter gender equations of the past. But, the trend in male responses to women’s progressiveness in the 21st century appears to be in increasing their domination and control.

In many communities, men assume moral policing of women’s behaviour, their clothing, and their freedoms of choice. Elsewhere they are the targets of war.

Fate of femaleness

In Afghanistan, young girls and women studying or teaching in schools, or appearing in public without the veil, are being subjected to acid attacks. In Pakistan’s Swat region, governance agreements are forged with the Taliban. In war-torn African countries, eighty percent of refugees are women and children, many of them the products of rape.

Governments and world leaders issue condemnations. But in nations challenged on many fronts, the social development of women doesn’t get high priority.

Immigrant women are hardly better off. The founder of a ‘positive’ Muslim TV channel in USA beheaded his wife for lodging complaints of domestic violence. The man has been charged with second-degree murder, perhaps only because of the location of the crime.

Indian culture?

In democratic India, the trend of forcing subservience seems to be catching on. In January 2009, a few dozen activists of Sri Ram Sena, a little known right-wing outfit, barged into a pub in Mangalore a city in the southern state of Karnataka and physically assaulted the patrons, young women and men, for behaviours anti ‘Indian culture’.


Further incidents have occurred of school or college-going boys and girls being hauled off public transport buses and harassed for talking or being together – especially if they belong to different communities.


No complaints

The young groups being beaten in public are intimidated. A teenaged girl reportedly committed suicide over such a humiliation.

None of the girls molested in Mangalore’s pubs filed police complaints against their attackers. They say policemen in the vicinity of the pubs had simply looked on during the incidents. Their question is “whom do we turn to?”

Initially, there was little reaction by the state’s police and administrative authorities. Media attention also encouraged the group’s leader to dismiss the episode as a "small thing" on national TV. He warned the public that unmarried couples caught celebrating Valentine’s Day would be forcibly wed.

Formal protests

But elsewhere in India, there have been sharp reactions from men and women, prominently carried in print, channel and electronic media. Public protests have mobilized.

The pub incidents even sparked rows between Centre and state. Fiery Union Minister for Women and Child Development, Renuka Chowdhury decried the (Hindu) “Talibanization”. The remarks irked the Mayor of the city, who decided to move court against her for inflammatory statements.

More diplomatically, Shabnam Hashmi, a member of the National Integration Council, Ministry of Home Affairs, submitted a memorandum to the state’s Governor, and met the state’s Police Commissioner to express her anguish and distress.


Cont’d 2...The power of pink

Monday, February 16, 2009

Accidents: The human factors


Synopsis: Contributing factors exist not just in the person but also in the dynamic, sometimes unknown surroundings.


Both novices and experienced personnel contribute to the human error causing 70 percent of accidents.

Levels of failure

Reporting systems are usually ineffective in identifying these human failures. Hence, while engineering or mechanical failures have significantly been reduced, human error ratios over four decades remain the same.

Researchers say that they actually occurs at four different levels that need appropriate analysis:


  • Unsafe acts of operators, like errors or violations by aircrew.
  • Preconditions for unsafe acts like physical, mental or psychological health of operators or crew resource mismanagement.
  • Unsafe supervision, like inadequacy or violations of supervision, poorly planned operations, and failure to correct known problems.
  • Organizational influences like resources management, organizational climate or operational processes.
Personality?

A study in 2001 held that a quarter of ‘human error’ accidents are attributable to personality. High or low scores on certain traits correlate with the ability to avoid accidents or be prone to them:

  • Dependability – conscientious and socially responsible
  • Agreeableness – not aggressive or self-centred
  • Openness – learning from experience and accepting suggestions from others.

High scores on the first two and low scores on the last decrease the likelihood of accidents. Low scores on first two causes competitiveness, and non-compliance with safety regulations. High score on the last leaves people dreamy and increases accident risk.


Profiles

Studies on pilot profiles however, failed to find a typical personality type. Important traits are intelligence, self-confidence, emotional maturity, adaptability, extraversion, and action orientation with desire for challenge and success. Combat pilots score highly on abstract thinking, stress tolerance, decisiveness and resilience.

Essentially operators in hazardous jobs need to be practical, sober and dependable. But a point with jet pilots appears to be a close relationship with their fathers. Also of the first 23 US astronauts in space flight, 21 were ‘first-born’.

Regarding gender, men in aviation score higher in competitiveness but lower in expressivity and striving for achievements. Women pilots appear to be more extraverted, agreeable and conscientious, having less openness and neuroticism than their male counterparts.



The surroundings

But some say labels merely enable people to blame their mistakes on their personality type. The point is factors exist not just in the person but also in the dynamic, sometimes unknown surroundings represented by:


  • Technology
  • Procedures
  • Physical and non-physical environment
  • Other people

People generally don’t go out with intention of causing accidents, but how they react to situations is important. That means interactions between the individual and objects or people around them are just as important.

The dynamics

Researchers believe that tests homogenize groups and the resulting average obtained becomes the ‘right stuff’. This obscures variability, and actual motivations for the job, because training and operational performances tend to differ.

Operations brings into focus adaptability, coping with stress, and a more crucial aspect to success – teamwork. Rising environmental pressures can cause personality conflicts, with operators either internalizing negativity or projecting it on others. This interferes with interpersonal relationships and individual contributions to team effort.


Comments/opinions, anyone??

References for “Accidents” blogposts:

All 155 Survive as Pilot Ditches Plane in Hudson

A human error analysis

Are you accident prone? (twmacademy.com)

Identifying the accident prone

Personality studies in air crew

Thursday, February 12, 2009

Accidents: Deviations from plan


Synopsis: A combination of random factors contributes to disaster happening - or being averted.


We tend to believe that forces beyond us control disasters. They happen following Murphy’s Law that everything that can go wrong, does. And, the people affected survive only by luck or chance.

Unexpected events

Disasters grow out of unexpected events interrupting or interfering with routine proceedings. They precipitate deviations from planned behaviour that invoke risks.

For example, the now-famous American Airways airliner 15(4)9 took off on a routine flight from La Guardia Airport, with about 156 people on board.

The flight path, however, crossed that of migratory birds. The plane collided with a flock of geese, within minutes of take off. Bird-hits are said to cost the American aviation industry up to 600 million USD annually.


Water rescue

The event caused both engines of the plane cut out, preventing its return to land. Using the icy waters as the only accessible runway, the captain ditched the plane into the Hudson River.

The most impact passengers suffered were being thrown against the seat ahead. The plane also stayed intact and level in the water, so they could clamber out onto the wings and floating door.

But experts say even five minutes’ exposure in those freezing temperatures would still have caused severe hypothermia if not fatalities.

Responders speeded up the rescue process, even driving an inflatable boat onto the plane’s wing. Paramedics found one passenger had broken legs and others with less serious injuries. Everybody, including an infant, survived the ordeal.

Random factors

The bird-hit damage raised the potential of disaster. But the skill and presence of mind of the aircrew and first responders on the ground made it a miraculous escape instead.

Not one isolated event, but a combination of random error factors contributes to disaster happening - or being averted. These include:


  • Situational factors like atmospheric conditions
  • Individual factors like perception, cognition and physiological responses of people
  • Specific personal factors like vision, age, experience, perceptual style and perceptual-motor relationships
  • Psychological qualities of the people involved


The Hudson miracle wasn’t all due to providence. While situational factors were the driving forces for disaster, the human factors - individual, personal and psychological - of key people withstood their power.

Processing state

The pilot, an airways safety consultant, former fighter pilot and commercial pilot for nearly three decades, also had extensive glider experience. He glided the plane onto water so it didn’t break up on impact. Since 9/11, ground rescue workers have trained long and hard at disaster management in different scenarios. Their combined competencies ensured that all aboard the ill-fated liner disembarked safely.

Every industry invests in safety, putting precautionary barriers especially in hazardous job situations. But the mere presence of procedures doesn’t guarantee safety. Each procedure also has inherent weaknesses or ‘blind spots’ whereby it only works under certain conditions, or up to a point.

Bridging the gap between the plan and reality needs creative thinking. It also depends upon individual ‘processing state’ – functioning at full alert to expect the unexpected, or multitasking on autopilot with attention divided.


Cont’d 2…The human factors